[Green] Fw: The myth of 'carbon neutral' | The Guardian

Thu Jan 26 06:38:52 CST 2023

Not good news.

"If you have a garden and a library, you have everything you need."-- Cicero
________________________________
From: Down to Earth <info at email.theguardian.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 26, 2023 7:02 AM
To: bennphil at hotmail.com <bennphil at hotmail.com>
Subject: The myth of 'carbon neutral' | The Guardian

What if 'carbon offsets' on flights, food and TV don't work?
[Down To Earth - The Guardian]
[This file photo taken on August 16, 2020, shows an aerial view of a burning area of Amazon rainforest reserve, south of Novo Progresso in Para state, Brazil.]
26/01/2023
‘Carbon offsets’ on flights, food and even TV claim to help the planet – what if they don’t?

Patrick Greenfield      [Patrick Greenfield]

Our investigation into rainforest offsets approved by Verra, the organisation that operates the world’s leading carbon standard, was driven by a simple question: are the carbon credits trustworthy?

Protecting the world’s remaining tropical rainforests will be crucial to meeting biodiversity and climate targets this decade. These ecosystems are home to some of the largest concentrations of life on Earth and the territories of numerous Indigenous communities who have repeatedly been shown to be the best stewards of nature. Conserving carbon-rich rainforests will require large amounts of money, improved governance in developing countries and changes to our economic systems.

Nature-based offsets have been presented as a way to fund their protection while providing money for rural and Indigenous communities who live in forests and other important ecosystems, all paid for those who pollute.

These credits are often used to substantiate the “carbon neutral” adverts we see everywhere: you can fly carbon neutral, eat carbon neutral ice-cream, watch a carbon-neutral TV programme and even make your entire life carbon neutral by paying for offsets, in theory cancelling out the emissions from greenhouse gases heating the Earth’s atmosphere, all for a few pounds, dollars or euros.

But our joint investigation<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQX03ymStNh34qMRFvlwu3BLu5E2Zq1DwB32GDTljpXz_QvhnOG08R-52MlRhJm1ZGt0inmEj_xmxFE8vvu44d1Hjd2-6SDKqYBsWp5BPcufXiyZ1igMC1k2UnocOU8VDd-58-FjoS0vJjyFDV_9VKw-GEl9fGafP5lodByk4pcjDUFTrct9zLMOPj61_oBiddwdB4FwGpII8sMfSMpiNbYB6iFlm8M_7PG6B2oHi9OgmmopOizjr7R0e4JSWqwlkbXCLQ8b7kKYAd7HBrQuTZbQ/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h26/91UxRu4Bz8JHwTMmATUkif116CfPSkoVTKMe5lqUHXc> with the German weekly Die Zeit<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXHYYK5xgIy2p3_W93VTXyClmYrTCiiqXK6YBcOk39KLdEyIzb4x4mZMtKtj9QwYsWltnM50cKGrwJBMRh_bbGAhUoZq2NneCgMhpH70SWh3e69wQw0vPTrb0tM2gTAdmjFbYn4jH6-k0ppuEBeY1pSWYnYHZ38JnEPrdduElZsbgbI_2aVdciuaW93mMYMORhAZBU0J-ViP5SADggxG6Cmf-_oEjMITnCa3l3-9v72QgnDFwPLtDZTRPsrqIQkrBJddCBlZ67ndYzcidAuB69lYwnfTSmVD4795DQO-L8tkfXxt4qh2O5Nrd0WEtN9Diw/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h27/h32TesZCIVVT2n2VPJZGNQ4wk45bVlcIFXIXvJF6sb0> and SourceMaterial<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQQvEfAPvUBsGTUmnI9saDmGC4IEqL_AGgAmkJerpxDQq06crMQkOP9WsbjRRBP_77x7dfkiMGRCVi8my453iiLwf60pYXFl3PZJvtQGYIWidaVWitFw6zYmw__b2VOzGvyywHsWtroC_WBaBNlXeJv7dSF8dj8rEt91cqh-PqW9ZH2HX3ToJTaEwgaIZrwvmQjmGeJkEqZsENx5U6H_Gv1dBj5FlMMKyCHl3Vxofkw1vZbH2dJFhUMYKy2DL1IwB1e8oe7weac7FQC1MEdyP5_31_Xroa0yGurLLEIwaDBzf/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h28/QnWQST-7JG6QquJwhHSFcilaULoNO-7ugXRo-FilKpA>, a non-profit investigative journalism organisation, indicates the current system is broken.

Based on analysis of a significant percentage of the Verra’s rainforest protection projects, more than 90% of their rainforest offset credits – among the most commonly used by companies – are likely to be worthless “phantom credits” that do not represent genuine carbon reductions. Verra strongly dispute these findings, arguing the conclusions reached by the studies are incorrect, and questions their methodology. The company point out their work since 2009 has allowed billions of dollars to be channelled to the vital work of preserving forests.

In Peru, we found evidence that a flagship scheme<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQWOunvUPGjr2otYDMCTW3NjSKVR2qoGD01gGroJAmm68l2T_AbBTgxs09T7caPFvAIRbVzzDtkIxNrWNpzvo8nKEYcS0VXYE4XQ0woySmXOwKXYAV_8qd6LE4047atZcJRbCpz94jOEpX17KAtuqF1dAsFBCqcXfk1b7ZvTrdO2fq9z6TiF8sgYszczYK3B4v1V6RB1begURMpInNPr6T7DYysAtKpERKryxNiBJReW-icLvhWgzdzHkUmPOOdvqc/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h29/V7Oa13RR-CQxwnS4UbCCfjqT8WoIUbPqJ409hTExmMA> operated by Conservation International and the country’s national park service had divided local communities and led to forced evictions of residents in the protected area.

We spoke with Indigenous communities<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQ_cWre0OZ1fldaYoCr_c25nqMU99YbGhu9Cgc3fKsdP3HA3JzI6HCAah2f2nU7kwoVfGd0lKYAFgKyrEYsS8TjIQ2IiMpWBt0p5eHby_VcznI18DbmhS_kRAqLt8vdQafXMuii4a6V2iNbSGpOfwU6MIBdhCxcZ0RJNzWtryVqM2SYJ7aKGtqSJ4wuvn94xTDZngdPtvWmeVJnFEcFaIkOOhnqshjRsUegQ4UWlQZDNRxfLJXqrdY3kkYaspn-E4k/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h30/C0QgAlLwNmnfoXBgUVv-uSdWko6UCr65v-QOGMVGoEs> from across the Amazon who warned they were being targeted by “carbon pirates” by western businesspeople who want to setup more offsetting schemes.

From Greta Thunberg<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/anB5BDNDuHMZ3XJHP1YCbsuNZdqB_IHUxzgJq4rvAILERs5avgOaaZWNUiPBrm5bsXoIw-hJg9g0u-5ODDCxra74wZfKm1Os5nc54Mq1BWZJCq3XSPYsPKms3dszHjMFAIadN1Ep_mE5-5-vvLKqzNz0_klPFbMcRtUuYmUguU7ZH2KN_06Cp3xYhjSZfNK_J7Mu3GCyTer-E0rVXODpnKZeUt2ItCgp1DeYEpwL3rUckFAKNaYwABZBW41ZG12c/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h31/v2z4ZO7HlVlngtcqSZN5vR102Cyy_ekNDSweij1iK98> to the office of the UN secretary general<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/anB5BDNDuHMZ3XJHP1YCbm6w6CiO0APAwPGcOSyBOjz_O94IGaQD2gL9uFyaWGuFBjHgnVyP0j7fR8mIb2afBtciIu0nY9Y8_8iJhqLXCpNdWrstofZ-9p3gffrXUzZ6a2tN267aRiSa8t3TktUr4R6STSSDebrOSDoXgL92FPA1vRJNc9z15Suvcc_nr3RFr7XW75AhMu_Pr20JPiwepYg0V0HO5hJHC5zaTuOPTg_PrPuxBqraSCSxgDOF5zHF/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h32/rLb-P_u93IVG2v4bGZssjMhsdEKLxjlamMi1MmKCCbA>, the reaction to our nine-month investigation has been one of shock and incredulity. There are no easy answers about what happens next.

Through the logic of offsetting, carbon is the main value of everything. The core finding of the investigation is that there are deep flaws in how we calculate the carbon value of conservation projects, not that they provide no benefit at all.

For some, the investigation’s findings are yet more proof of a bad idea making climate change worse, while others acknowledge flaws but are fearful of the consequences of losing an important source of funding for conservation.

Carbon markets are part of the Paris agreement and the unregulated voluntary sector is unlikely to disappear as more and more corporations make net zero commitments. However countries choose to respond to the environmental crises of our time, experts have repeatedly warned it must be science-based.

“Many carbon offsetting claims are not real. This has to stop! We must ensure high integrity demand and supply on carbon and biodiversity,” said former WWF head Marco Lambertini in response to our findings.

“Companies may compensate only for absolutely unavoidable impacts, after exhausting all avoidance and mitigation options.”

[https://i.guim.co.uk/img/uploads/2022/10/25/down-to-earth-divider.png?width=650&quality=100&dpr=2&s=bf974a1cbf5ebbd8811ff2ca170a4cd0]
Composted Reads

Story of the week

Revealed: how US transition to electric cars threatens environmental havoc<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYucGDibc2UTFNpJdWKKfojAKZwje1YqAwe1K5JaDTcbaqvbxnw7m0t9bb9FCqLh4psmvAjibSGr2xy2tV2pa_Dv7ITbHyNH_T_J18pVhGM4803MkSRQnijJTWK7ps9-y2C22GmabDWN9BGGSvn3LPmEAPbzZQLHj4X4TwTNf4aSmtE40MO9-L3TBsIuYvvQUeFDp-2Wjw7ayLJhCxOqdmgIgPJ3R1iKe9A34qoARPtp7_bcj51k678QOGbBDD8esaXxpUFPQXemcXRQu_tFZO/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h33/SlofisFkDViCSeAsSSrjjtU5FJM_wT-3RyEyH1zgIEg>       [Revealed: how US transition to electric cars threatens environmental havoc] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYucGDibc2UTFNpJdWKKfojAKZwje1YqAwe1K5JaDTcbaqvbxnw7m0t9bb9FCqLh4psmvAjibSGr2xy2tV2pa_Dv7ITbHyNH_T_J18pVhGM4803MkSRQnijJTWK7ps9-y2C22GmabDWN9BGGSvn3LPmEAPbzZQLHj4X4TwTNf4aSmtE40MO9-L3TBsIuYvvQUeFDp-2Wjw7ayLJhCxOqdmgIgPJ3R1iKe9A34qoARPtp7_bcj51k678QOGbBDD8esaXxpUFPQXemcXRQu_tFZO/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h34/R1JIFd24E9XLKn7EKR2zT4xVcRSwIjKEHajjAkhHgjc>

The good news

King Charles redirects £1bn windfarm profits towards ‘public good’<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sG6DHXqEhxhJt-69uXgeqvqs11bbGjoxaJK7almaLfa73jMsk1JiL3KlQaQxNJKuNv_BzkXpAtwUpR2bTV_kNVKbmR6vC51qKkzWU3UAjhAdFchiWR97uhMg8aN5ucPcH1xPKl7eYu7CV4JCY2Hm72VTZOuQNw4DgI9JSQlGlrzyriDPo4yoCrJ2C_JQlcnNgoXrmSOM8BsO5uhQglrYhODK0KPAkXbp8L8WQRzmYKuIn6m7vzH4f-CFoUmAAyws2qylrBYSm3ZSBXSbkYWUuK/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h35/Va39vNHASzAQc3S67v_JWCAyqah3yUyRdHQ3L4h6uhs>       [King Charles redirects £1bn windfarm profits towards ‘public good’] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sG6DHXqEhxhJt-69uXgeqvqs11bbGjoxaJK7almaLfa73jMsk1JiL3KlQaQxNJKuNv_BzkXpAtwUpR2bTV_kNVKbmR6vC51qKkzWU3UAjhAdFchiWR97uhMg8aN5ucPcH1xPKl7eYu7CV4JCY2Hm72VTZOuQNw4DgI9JSQlGlrzyriDPo4yoCrJ2C_JQlcnNgoXrmSOM8BsO5uhQglrYhODK0KPAkXbp8L8WQRzmYKuIn6m7vzH4f-CFoUmAAyws2qylrBYSm3ZSBXSbkYWUuK/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h36/QwuvFz-8aLOVaOVaFHiCFWJ4bur9lemIPJHe4iUulLM>
‘Toadzilla’: giant cane toad believed to be the largest of its species found in Australia<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQ2V9cgiJiR48OApdWs7m9qqMeohqamR2wMY5UVUKVMA9udu-NSS1cyXdh7D3Of4x-ctkz6w0_hUwpH4safmfApUTZNLK_Mz5wHrTPDTB_zMetlD1x07dX9S3giKHqD38lYYrJlhOwjHwa0-eeMn8h1a2u25EgFMyeRiDObUq3GhgrTB47yquB2WHSDub4HmmRdOXyO4T9AxJHF6jx-sBnHI9tPDZnlt1VBJzmUtK8JKAE9q6OM-edSN_jbRtlsald-7tLZkuMSEwhNyXabTO0aDeFSuSoyRlOMsxQzXMY65UPRBTzIGO7i-emeUy5wUby/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h37/fr5_I7LZ_gwe8Xon9IbuCHhRl_3OhNgFu94CoIZtFr8>        [‘Toadzilla’: giant cane toad believed to be the largest of its species found in Australia] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQ2V9cgiJiR48OApdWs7m9qqMeohqamR2wMY5UVUKVMA9udu-NSS1cyXdh7D3Of4x-ctkz6w0_hUwpH4safmfApUTZNLK_Mz5wHrTPDTB_zMetlD1x07dX9S3giKHqD38lYYrJlhOwjHwa0-eeMn8h1a2u25EgFMyeRiDObUq3GhgrTB47yquB2WHSDub4HmmRdOXyO4T9AxJHF6jx-sBnHI9tPDZnlt1VBJzmUtK8JKAE9q6OM-edSN_jbRtlsald-7tLZkuMSEwhNyXabTO0aDeFSuSoyRlOMsxQzXMY65UPRBTzIGO7i-emeUy5wUby/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h38/ZN1ooFfk3Hw7Rk48EzFLV7w1I1skktlY-Ja4sudaHlM>

The bad news

People exposed to weedkiller chemical have cancer biomarkers in urine – study<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYucGDibc2UTFNpJdWKKfo4wrq20C_ZmaDE49UGg5Fd2DFXIrcUnXosz62mwolDSIWhv7RJ98Sh9VUQRUvprUNH_V3I1jeXKt-LfJxsGs7Z1CcllB04LmKxMSIQ2Jcml8tV_Ylg7ODEe-1b_w_61R7EEv_83uwyQ7ENeQWjAvTq6oHF0kmlKP8hwa8o5cbO_nENA-59oiC5F-QHoEXHYNd4XMz0TfwkyYqsN6cuLQtKPEkVaHAqLINr52AuUjYLsJGKd-J3687405taFjgP5LW/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h39/YJqdEeM_28WEnbhiNZhVjfKT6bvNe32S_C528IAUux4>    [People exposed to weedkiller chemical have cancer biomarkers in urine – study] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYucGDibc2UTFNpJdWKKfo4wrq20C_ZmaDE49UGg5Fd2DFXIrcUnXosz62mwolDSIWhv7RJ98Sh9VUQRUvprUNH_V3I1jeXKt-LfJxsGs7Z1CcllB04LmKxMSIQ2Jcml8tV_Ylg7ODEe-1b_w_61R7EEv_83uwyQ7ENeQWjAvTq6oHF0kmlKP8hwa8o5cbO_nENA-59oiC5F-QHoEXHYNd4XMz0TfwkyYqsN6cuLQtKPEkVaHAqLINr52AuUjYLsJGKd-J3687405taFjgP5LW/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h40/RIVsLvF_ve6kUQq6G1owBUZEMVBOHOuIHKFVdIq31v4>
France to take legal action over ‘nightmare’ plastic pellet spill<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQTx0H0-VXEqRZeX0PdDOlqN8A5jP0JM1ND7iSqWTOWgMRV9Yn8DaAyj-v_XEuuaibKUAYrhrjzLFWZteXSki2TU1xvXqjSUYy4PPEwO1wgd-GzwkZowadlSA_Y2rOrSXp2YPpb503Vf-S99KSWV4Fb7E6VsBDRgk2yjD9sX7dssIY9LMW5_4NhGn_AhvdScxtisCutmgn5gUNutU0-I7AEUu9KqLHdlIP65-tr-m2ZXVt0QBeVUq81Oh9lyrf78iZHSbxx8AIzqinJBLURWTKZg/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h41/1RB0_BeC1Qtu_Ce_9R_br3AUbPbmPXyj73O0aEYxXpE>  [France to take legal action over ‘nightmare’ plastic pellet spill] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00sy_-q9xCcdQQjMxRI6QJIQTx0H0-VXEqRZeX0PdDOlqN8A5jP0JM1ND7iSqWTOWgMRV9Yn8DaAyj-v_XEuuaibKUAYrhrjzLFWZteXSki2TU1xvXqjSUYy4PPEwO1wgd-GzwkZowadlSA_Y2rOrSXp2YPpb503Vf-S99KSWV4Fb7E6VsBDRgk2yjD9sX7dssIY9LMW5_4NhGn_AhvdScxtisCutmgn5gUNutU0-I7AEUu9KqLHdlIP65-tr-m2ZXVt0QBeVUq81Oh9lyrf78iZHSbxx8AIzqinJBLURWTKZg/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h42/6rqxy6F1XQpQQZoBZFsWtzotnSnvMwPLN6nToZRjyKI>

Essential reads

Why our diet is narrower than ever – and the UK urgently needs to save these seven foods<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tPt9foYVKGUIVKeva8lzwLqryDMNmqOAuECn8alHhXC1OsqXP1u7b6Kq7LXgkLZ8gLWuJKtZgaXl_hmYrgtGKrV5NPvU_DchT2y1RTtnd-_Cb1XyHDohbxg8O5ySy7OIJe53OMIjbtWapQAe8RWPxZ0CbOCFCwZTmYQV5dyMXN-mLuZSNJyH3gz6oSMf7b_Cc7PgvDG1A_WkM9oBi3dHKTdz_YAyWIwNAGick-Yee3lM1WMW9IoeE96Aa-hQLT804uSOEnIkOgG2OrFeAgcyl9I9Gb92ZEGtM7Dsvujnmq2TEPm8zQfzD6MEo3m6_SwP0/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h43/sJfcEjLjbYeYzkcdzQn_mtdYiKnnzgnJvpUYNe7hyp0>      [Why our diet is narrower than ever – and the UK urgently needs to save these seven foods] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tPt9foYVKGUIVKeva8lzwLqryDMNmqOAuECn8alHhXC1OsqXP1u7b6Kq7LXgkLZ8gLWuJKtZgaXl_hmYrgtGKrV5NPvU_DchT2y1RTtnd-_Cb1XyHDohbxg8O5ySy7OIJe53OMIjbtWapQAe8RWPxZ0CbOCFCwZTmYQV5dyMXN-mLuZSNJyH3gz6oSMf7b_Cc7PgvDG1A_WkM9oBi3dHKTdz_YAyWIwNAGick-Yee3lM1WMW9IoeE96Aa-hQLT804uSOEnIkOgG2OrFeAgcyl9I9Gb92ZEGtM7Dsvujnmq2TEPm8zQfzD6MEo3m6_SwP0/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h44/XoguX_6DRsnEhFlb3k8gsi55OqFuwzB5exfcnUoDo_A>
This is an era of plentiful, cheap, renewable energy, but the fossil fuel dinosaurs can’t admit it | Zoe Williams<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYaqT6ZMySWX2FYAKIWSx4Mc89z1eVjXzD9iOLEmvecmUhcAGYGVmweVE7FU08yareycc0cJsHoa1mSFech41hFPfLXWTW3B3Ody1jGau6r7MOwkq3pyTeK6Fvi1d7uyE9D_g909WLWu_0fCjsIjdGt10wIoqRj27RO9BXEILRUkrpjU6ytMKWzTcSsW20Fr5icanQk7GaiorPF6v4q4-HGBKam00n1PicQQWl4lTm1pd5zo2NEwtvfyAEsUWKR68JXjiLMMQcj_6yXvzZv7r2/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h45/j1ES9afxEIqLE9B5dIG-weL3CNfqsZ4QD8kXPEpo_rg>        [This is an era of plentiful, cheap, renewable energy, but the fossil fuel dinosaurs can’t admit it | Zoe Williams] <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00tYaqT6ZMySWX2FYAKIWSx4Mc89z1eVjXzD9iOLEmvecmUhcAGYGVmweVE7FU08yareycc0cJsHoa1mSFech41hFPfLXWTW3B3Ody1jGau6r7MOwkq3pyTeK6Fvi1d7uyE9D_g909WLWu_0fCjsIjdGt10wIoqRj27RO9BXEILRUkrpjU6ytMKWzTcSsW20Fr5icanQk7GaiorPF6v4q4-HGBKam00n1PicQQWl4lTm1pd5zo2NEwtvfyAEsUWKR68JXjiLMMQcj_6yXvzZv7r2/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h46/fnQThXI7foF-V3nSy6L2JsbBwyAKgr5HUymvsuzEUjM>
Read more on The Guardian<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00vkmAG2Jab-Uh9gq9o-RcRdCWNrb6_T6QOCX7mGD-EE9yLpAzi95zZhKwREGpNg7c6vApUqOLT1tD_SdaHhQ3Y-O8RErFl46lVl77xChxHi8vLPa62VOBkTTDbdb49k-jqu3eI1uAN3GCEfgXhzHYqjI5NUZW0BCKcQaSZghmq0kxF0ddRLp46wlDufXWlhrgw/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h47/CJRodiEx2v0iHWGOakafzxfwGIjHWyX0sNy4w-mIFEo>     <https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00vkmAG2Jab-Uh9gq9o-RcRdCWNrb6_T6QOCX7mGD-EE9yLpAzi95zZhKwREGpNg7c6vApUqOLT1tD_SdaHhQ3Y-O8RErFl46lVl77xChxHi8vLPa62VOBkTTDbdb49k-jqu3eI1uAN3GCEfgXhzHYqjI5NUZW0BCKcQaSZghmq0kxF0ddRLp46wlDufXWlhrgw/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h48/xYEJljqEpFq00AG-5858r10PA_i2uRTeM4TGR4RJe1A>
[https://i.guim.co.uk/img/uploads/2022/10/25/arrow-right-green300.png?width=30&quality=85&dpr=2&s=07e91ff6a504e810b2cc8501ff7beaf6]

The most important number of the climate crisis:
418.3
Atmospheric CO2 in parts per million, 24 January 2023
Source: NOAA
[https://cdn.braze.eu/appboy/communication/assets/image_assets/images/63b5a06cdaa88d042cb39c5f/original.png?1672847468]<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00vutN_oIz84I2EqoCXvYBx20xq86pIbr8RfTnphpw711Kq5R9JFzsY6NsscXFCP8dwX-H63vuY9k19VCmqnXZznce8zC96RK4MmHRkaU8QlBSyscrJgyrvGzZTr0AsGJd_ju-8KtF7HeH0-719QKjbq8aVw0QLGTUoILPCu1rq-qzIeisYhNSTOIkw6plfF_IYJ0dDZ4qCsyJ9yoUQ1BQmhOu8EOsDnZvsBKCHVlBCzVCOGND5M1pUrdqN24ARub8tnpaWkkohotCCr8KOCOON4/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h49/n0_BxuE9pZocZOrmuxA-Ml3uLJ0NrSumhuxQympmRn0>

[https://i.guim.co.uk/img/uploads/2022/10/25/down-to-earth-divider.png?width=650&quality=100&dpr=2&s=bf974a1cbf5ebbd8811ff2ca170a4cd0]
Climate Hero – Mary Gartshore
[Mary Gartshore, a climate hero.]

First urged to explore and document her local environment by her parents in 1950s Ontario, Canada, for Mary Gartshore a love of nature and want to preserve our planet have been lifelong tenets.

Gartshore went on to study zoology at university and work on wildlife surveys in Cameroon, the Ivory Coast and beyond, and restoration projects in Ecuador. Resettling in Ontario with her partner, she rededicated herself to helping her homeland prosper.

“I learned the life history traits of some 500+ plant species and realised biodiversity was the key to the success of these projects,” says Mary. Since 1992, she estimates she has “carried out over 800 hectares of seed-based ecological restoration projects”, and mentored countless others on the benefits of biodiversity for humans, our planet and the animals we share it with.

Nominated by reader Cynthia Brink

If you’d like to nominate a climate hero, email downtoearth at theguardian.com

Get in touch
If you have any questions or comments about any of our newsletters please email downtoearth at theguardian.com<mailto:downtoearth at theguardian.com>
Manage your emails<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/_aTD46XvGNsn-UWpVjTkvd00TM1KxNOYWnVuqz3edeD1p7GwvTect899FfZNb8JDHlIL1Jih1gZmDTIXXY5W8Zp6tMgbY8QZ3rP346U6JbtPJoJxaXt9I0BSrq9-CVJBrxE2zIo15RhkloKw2nDaNd9NPTOAm_0BZt1zaoaiExs1EfW-4pqNtz2W8XhXOdJNwtnxowWaf7Z7ro2JNpt027ehVNlRrx5JgVrX48GQNd0/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h50/Cb0RFn3YPdOQ4gLPajQcy7CzwIK8XIk80A1b1IIir8M> | Unsubscribe<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/_aTD46XvGNsn-UWpVjTkvd00TM1KxNOYWnVuqz3edeDl5auYzadGV9-0a5s-92s07WBP-qKHbs0uCX_9KNhCJNlfhOrpt2idukC3jngCLmV1g0UuD3fVkXoPNISBkUEjAuEBoozZr0PaXUEszam42wo120phe0hPh_RjawnrMwb_RbQAgzJ0fUgdSJjcl4sR/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h51/W1vxwKsd7DcMtfvbZuqGGQtnv_4mjWzHayyll99mBFg>
[https://www.theguardian.com/uk]<https://ablink.email.theguardian.com/ss/c/TBl-lE0k4WbTlFRn6v-lQXxTpTslqnvUsR2ofAkC00u0sM2FVknXwCA11BRFIYbxHNc12nKrVTzT0_cS4lIcQRa04Mp7V5ZVekfBWFcEeCY9FV5MDr0UafsPATJ4gKyfeAqlsDhxldm5EfgSO6iBoNVN_rmz7hf0NSZ9w2I8vCuASfBZcBlBM4gDxSRSvJEj1b0PRAgxVsYrlqSJb_34SQ/3t6/5vYX5_weQMeSots5HefNQw/h52/4tXVju7gPJRGDOR2ckjkvJsYeFSUr4wMeYvEQDHgZTE>

You are receiving this email because you are a subscriber to Down To Earth. Guardian News & Media Limited - a member of Guardian Media Group PLC. Registered Office: Kings Place, 90 York Way, London, N1 9GU. Registered in England No. 908396
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://fuusm.org/pipermail/green_fuusm.org/attachments/20230126/4f22d885/attachment.htm>